Why These Are the Top 10 Auto Insurance Companies in the USA
Rankings come from 2024 NAIC data, updated for 2025 trends. We look at market share, premiums written, J.D. Power scores, and rates for a 35-year-old driver with a clean record. The car insurance company rankings 2025 show growth in premiums by 13%, due to more cars and higher repair costs.
Insurance market share in the USA favors big names. State Farm and Progressive alone take 35%. Smaller ones like USAA shine in service. Customer satisfaction auto insurer scores from J.D. Power (out of 1,000) help too. The national average is 697.
Factors to compare auto insurance companies: Rates, coverage discounts, and complaints. Full coverage vs liability insurance: Full adds collision and comprehensive, costing $2,433 a year on average.
How to choose the best auto insurance company: Match your needs. New driver? Look for teen discounts. Family? Bundle home and auto.
Average car insurance premium in the USA: $736 minimum, $2,433 full. Shop quotes to save 20-30%.
The Top 10 Auto Insurance Companies in the USA for 2025
Here is the list. Data from NAIC, J.D. Power, and rate studies.
1. State Farm: The Largest Auto Insurance Provider
State Farm tops with 18.87% market share. Founded in 1922 by George Mecherle, a farmer-turned-agent, it started for rural drivers. Now, it serves 58 million policies with $68 billion in premiums.
Rates: $778 minimum, $2,721 full (6% over average).
Coverage: Liability, collision comprehensive. Add-ons like roadside and rental.
Customer Satisfaction: J.D. Power 710; AM Best A++.
Pros: 19,000 agents; Drive Safe & Save saves 30%.
Cons: No new policies in MA/RI; BBB F from complaints.
Best for: Families. Bundling saves 20%.
2. Progressive: Top-Rated Car Insurance Companies for Discounts
Progressive holds a 16.73% share. Started in 1937, it grew via TV ads with Flo. Premiums hit $60 billion.
Rates: $718 minimum, $2,452 full (near average).
Coverage: Full options plus rideshare, mechanical breakdown.
Customer Satisfaction: J.D. Power 672; AM Best A+.
Pros: Snapshot app saves 40%; accident forgiveness.
Cons: Lower claims scores.
Best for: High-risk drivers. Insures DUIs.
3. Geico: Leading Auto Insurance Brands for Low Rates
Geico has an 11.63% share. Berkshire Hathaway has owned it since 1996. Founded in 1936 for government workers, it now covers all.
Rates: $519 minimum, $1,939 full (42% below average).
Coverage: 16 discounts; add-ons like roadside, gap.
Customer Satisfaction: J.D. Power 692; AM Best A++.
Pros: Easy online quotes; DriveEasy saves 25%.
Cons: Market share dipped slightly.
Best for: Budget shoppers. Cheapest for full coverage.
4. Allstate: Major Auto Insurance Companies with Perks
Allstate claims a 10.19% share. Sears 1931, it went public in 1993. Premiums: $36.58 billion.
Rates: $1,000 minimum, $2,762 full (36% over for minimum).
Coverage: Accident forgiveness; Milewise pay-per-mile in 18 states.
Customer Satisfaction: J.D. Power 691; AM Best A+.
Pros: Drivewise saves 25%; strong bundling.
Cons: Higher rates for some.
Best for: Low-mileage drivers. Up to 40% off.
5. USAA: Reliable Auto Insurance Companies for Military
USAA has a 6.17% share. Founded in 1922 by Army officers, it serves military families only. Premiums: $22.13 billion.
Rates: $433 minimum, $1,722 full (70% below average).
Coverage: Deployment coverage; bundling saves 15%.
Customer Satisfaction: J.D. Power 726 (top); AM Best A++.
Pros: Best service; low complaints.
Cons: Military only.
Best for: Veterans. OEM parts in claims.
6. Farmers: Best National Car Insurance Companies for Customization
Farmers take 3.76% share. Started in 1928 in LA, now under Zurich. Premiums: $13.5 billion.
Rates: $952 minimum, $2,973 full (29% over).
Coverage: 23 discounts; accident-free forgiveness after 3 years.
Customer Satisfaction: J.D. Power 706; AM Best A.
Pros: Rideshare add-on; agent network.
Cons: Not in all states.
Best for: Custom needs. Many extras.
7. Liberty Mutual: Top Vehicle Insurance Providers for Add-Ons
Liberty Mutual has a 3.27% share. Founded in 1912, it went public in 2000. Premiums down to $11.74 billion.
Rates: Vary; full around $2,500.
Coverage: MexPro for Mexico; waived deductibles for teachers.
Customer Satisfaction: J.D. Power 717; AM Best A.
Pros: Lifetime repair guarantee; bundling.
Cons: Higher complaints.
Best for: Global drivers. RightTrack saves 30%.
8. Travelers: USA Car Insurance Comparison Winner for Affordability
Travelers holds 2% share. Oldest in 1864, it merged in 2004. Premiums: $7.18 billion.
Rates: $684 minimum, $1,937 full (below average).
Coverage: IntelliDrive saves 30%; rideshare.
Customer Satisfaction: J.D. Power 684; AM Best A++.
Pros: Hybrid discounts; strong in NY.
Cons: Smaller share.
Best for: Safe drivers. Top regional scores.
9. AAA: Affordable Car Insurance in the USA with Perks
AAA entered the top 10 with a 1.8% share. From 1902, motor clubs, insurance varied by state. Premiums: $6.47 billion.
Rates: $716 minimum, $2,743 full (near average).
Coverage: Roadside with membership ($65/year).
Customer Satisfaction: J.D. Power 674; AM Best A.
Pros: Discounts for seniors; travel perks.
Cons: Varies by state.
Best for: Members. Strong in CA.
10. American Family: Best Auto Insurance Companies in the USA for Families
American Family has a 1.72% share. Founded in 1927 for farmers, now in 19 states. Premiums: $6.17 billion.
Rates: $952 minimum, $2,196 full (below for full).
Coverage: Bundling saves 23%; teen discounts.
Customer Satisfaction: J.D. Power 692; AM Best A.
Pros: Low complaints; customization.
Cons: Limited states.
Best for: Families. Good student discounts.
Comparison of the Top 10 Auto Insurance Companies in the USA
USA car insurance comparison table for full coverage rates (2025 averages):
| Rank | Company | Market Share | Full Rate | J.D. Power | Best For |
| 1 | State Farm | 18.87% | $2,721 | 710 | Families |
| 2 | Progressive | 16.73% | $2,452 | 672 | Discounts |
| 3 | Geico | 11.63% | $1,939 | 692 | Budget |
| 4 | Allstate | 10.19% | $2,762 | 691 | Low Mileage |
| 5 | USAA | 6.17% | $1,722 | 726 | Military |
| 6 | Farmers | 3.76% | $2,973 | 706 | Custom |
| 7 | Liberty Mutual | 3.27% | $2,500 | 717 | Add-Ons |
| 8 | Travelers | 2% | $1,937 | 684 | Safe Drivers |
| 9 | AAA | 1.8% | $2,743 | 674 | Members |
| 10 | American Family | 1.72% | $2,196 | 692 | Families |
Top 10 auto insurance companies in the USA ranked by coverage and service: USAA leads in service, Geico in coverage.
Best car insurance companies1 in the US for full coverage in 2025: Geico, USAA.
Which auto insurance company has the best customer reviews in the USA: USAA (726 J.D. Power).
Comparison of top-rated auto insurance providers by price and claims: Geico is cheap, and USAA claims top.
Largest2 and most reliable car insurance companies in America: State Farm size, USAA reliability.
What are the top 10 car insurance companies in the USA right now? As above.
Best car insurance for new drivers and families in the US: State Farm, American Family.
Top auto insurance companies with high claim approval rates: USAA, Farmers (95%).
Most popular car insurance companies in the USA by state: State Farm in 48 states, Geico in 50.
USA car insurance list with pros, cons, and average annual rates: See table.
How We Ranked the Top 10 Auto Insurance Companies in the USA
We used NAIC market share, J.D. Power satisfaction, AM Best financials, and rates from Quadrant. The best insurance for drivers in America balances all.
Auto insurance reviews and ratings: From 90,000 J.D. Power surveys.
Cheapest car insurance by state: Varies; Geico is low in CA, State Farm in TX.
Tips to Choose from the Top 10 Auto Insurance Companies in the USA
- Get Quotes: Use apps from Geico, Progressive.
- Check Discounts: Bundling, safe driver.
- Read Reviews: NAIC complaints are low for USAA.
- Match Needs: Military? USAA. Budget? Geico.
- Compare Coverage: Full for new cars.
How to choose the best auto insurance company: Shop 3+ from this list.
Common Questions About Top Auto Insurance Companies
Rates up 13% in 2025 from inflation.
FAQs
Top 10 auto insurance companies in the USA ranked by coverage and service?
USAA, Travelers, State Farm.
Best car insurance companies in the US for full coverage in 2025?
Geico, USAA.
Which auto insurance company has the best customer reviews in the USA?
USAA.
Comparison of top-rated auto insurance providers by price and claims?
Geico price, USAA claims.
Largest and most reliable car insurance companies in America?
State Farm largest3, and USAA is reliable.
Conclusion
The top 10 auto insurance companies in the USA for 2025 offer strong options. State Farm leads in size, USAA service, and Geico rates. Use this USA car insurance comparison to pick. Shop quotes to save.
Which company will you quote first?
References
- U.S. News. (2025). Best Car Insurance Companies. https://www.usnews.com/insurance/auto/best-car-insurance-companies ↩︎
- CNBC. (2025). Largest Car Insurance Companies. https://www.cnbc.com/select/largest-car-insurance-companies/ ↩︎
- MarketWatch. (2025). Largest Car Insurance Companies. https://www.marketwatch.com/insurance-services/auto-insurance/largest-car-insurance-companies ↩︎
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/how-to-get-acrylic-paint-off-clothes-5323500-10-742f78f12b3a4779a83b1f49d3463f60.jpg "How to Get Acrylic Paint Out of Clothes")
